Monday, October 11, 2010

Standing for Something

Historical Contextualization
Vasili Surikov, the creator of this masterpiece of Russian art, lived in the 19th century, about two centuries after this tragic incident. The painting depicts a poignant part of Russian history, the Raskol or schism of the Russian Orthodox Church.
After the conversion of Ancient Rus to Christianity by King Vladimir in 988 AD, the orthodox church in Russia underwent many changes which led to its splitting in 1667, the large majority following an influential priest named Nikon who had done all he could to reconcile the Russian Orthodox church with the ancient Greek writings on which they had based their religion. A fair number of people, however, found it difficult to just throw away their old way of believing; thus they are called the Old Believers. The new reformed church considered such people heretics and persecuted and killed thousands of them. In this depiction, a famous Old Believer, Feodosia Morozova, is being carted to a dungeon where she would spend about 4 long years and eventually starve to death. Here Feodosia is shown with her hand up, and two fingers in the air, the middle finger bent slightly to match the length of the index finger, showing the way the Old Believers cross themselves, in contrast to how the reformers started to cross themselves, with three fingers –the thumb, index and middle fingers brought together. She is revered as a martyr and still serves as a symbol of bravery and loyalty for Old Believers today.
It is important to note the Feodosia Morozova was a fairly important figure in society before her dreadful incarceration and agonizing death. She was born in a family that held the high rank of Okolnichy, meaning they were close the Tzar. She married into a rich and influential family; her husband’s brother was the Tzar’s own personal tutor. She held a high position in the Russian court all her life until she aggressively upheld her religious beliefs and suffered and died as a result.

3 comments:

  1. Wow! This is really detailed. My only question is, "what is the name of the painting?" I would assume "Standing for Something", since that is the title of your essay, but I'm not completely sure. I can't wait to read the rest of your essay.

    ReplyDelete
  2. It's good. You really studied up on this painting. The description of Feodosia Morozova is impressive. You used great diction to describe the situation surrounding the painting.
    I think it might be better to describe Morozova first and then the events in Russia, as that would give a more personal opinion before a 3rd person-type deal.

    ReplyDelete
  3. ... and then what? It feels like at the end that you are vamping up to something, but then it's over. Perhaps moving the ending sentences to more directly preface the introduction of Feodosia would help ease the transition out of the historical part of your paper.

    You historical context is exhaustive, but as one who has not read up on 19th century Russian history, I felt a bit lost at a few points.

    I felt like the first half of the paragraph bore little relevance to the overall gist of the context: that the Old Believers were persecuted as heretics and the Feodosia was a brave soul who stood defiantly for her beliefs. I may be guilty of the same in my own writing, so I will end here.

    I am sure that with a minimal amount of exertion you will be able to sculpt this, and the rest of the paper, into a superb essay. Keep it up, Adam

    ReplyDelete